A problem with a proof that $L^{p_{2}}\subseteq L^{p_{1}}$ for $1\leq p_{1}\leq p_{2}\leq\infty$

107 Views Asked by At

In a functional analysis course I saw a claim that for $1\leq p_{1}\leq p_{2}\leq\infty$we have it that $L^{p_{2}}\subseteq L^{p_{1}}$

I have a few problems with the proof given, and I would appreciate some clarifications. The proof given is (my comments are in $[]$):

Acuatlly, we will prove that $$ id:\,(C([a,b]),||\ldotp||_{p_{2}})\to(C([a,b]),||\ldotp||_{p_{1}}) $$

is continuous.

Let $f\in C([a.b])$. fix $0<\alpha<1$ and define:

$$ A=\{x\in[a,b]\mid|f(x)|>1\}\,,\, B=\{x\in[a,b]\mid\alpha\leq|f(x)|<1\}\,,\, C=\{x\in[a,b]\mid|f(x)|<\alpha\} $$

Then: $$ \int_{a}^{b}|f|^{p_{1}}=\int_{A}|f|^{p_{1}}+\int_{B}|f|^{p_{1}}+\int_{C}|f|^{p_{1}} $$

$$ \leq\int_{A}|f|^{p_{2}}+\int_{B}1+\int_{C}\alpha^{p_{1}} $$

$$ \leq||f||_{p_{2}}^{p_{2}}+\mu(B)+(b-a)\alpha^{p_{1}} $$

[those $3$ line are denoted as $(1)$]

[I don't think that the next line follows from what's done already] $$ ||f||_{p_{1}}^{p_{1}}\geq\int_{B}|f|^{p_{2}}\geq\alpha^{p_{2}}\mu(B) $$

[denote the above as $(\star)$]

$$ \implies\mu(B)\leq\frac{||f||_{p_{2}}^{p_{2}}}{\alpha^{p_{2}}} $$

set this in $(1)$ and get $$ ||f||_{p_{1}}^{p_{1}}\leq||f||_{p_{2}}^{p_{2}}+\frac{||f||_{p_{2}}^{p_{2}}}{\alpha^{p_{2}}}+(b-a)\alpha^{p_{1}} $$

Set $$ \alpha=||f||_{p_{2}}^{\frac{1}{2}} $$

$$ \implies||f||_{p_{2}}^{p_{2}}+||f||_{p_{2}}^{\frac{p_{2}}{2}}+(b-a)\alpha^{p_{1}} $$

And we see the required continuity.

My question are:

  1. How did we get the first inequality in $(\star)$ ?

  2. Why can we set $\alpha=||f||_{p_{2}}^{\frac{1}{2}}$ ? i.e why $0<\alpha<1$ ?

  3. Why what we want to prove follows from the continuity mentioned, and how did it follow from the last line ?

  4. Why did we star with $f\in C([a,b])$ ? I thought the elements of $L^{p}$ just have integrability constraints on them, not continuity constraints (I guess that this relates to the last question)

  5. Doesn't the last line just say that $\int|f|^{p_{1}}<\infty$ and that's what we want to prove ?

P.S I realize those are more questions here then a usual post, I will give $150$ point bounty to the accepted answer.