At least how many people are sending emails to each other

153 Views Asked by At

There are 10 students in class. Every student sent an email to exactly 5 of them. At least how many people who sent emails to each other?

My approach : consider 10 vertices as 10 students and edges representing the emails

so complete graph with 10 vertices have 45 edges

now changing all undirected edges to directed there will still be no 2 students who are sending emails to each other because we changed undirected to directed so there are no cycles between vertices of length 2.

Now we got 5 remaining edges or emails to send as soon as we'll add these 5 directed edges, we'll get 6 more people at minimum.

Am i going wrong somewhere because answer given is 5.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Assuming the question is "What is the minimum number of pairs of students who sent emails to each other?", there must be at least $5$ pairs of students who sent emails to each. There are $\binom{10}{2}=45$ pairs of students, meaning that if we must distribute $10*5=50$ edges among $45$ pairs, then by the pigeonhole principle there must be at least $5$ pairs with $2$ emails. To finish the proof that this is the maximum lower bound, we can construct a graph with $50$ directed edges with exactly $5$ pairs with $2$ emails between them. This is not difficult, so I leave it to you.