Bochner Integral: Approximability

252 Views Asked by At

Problem

Given a measure space $\Omega$ and a Banach space $E$.

Consider a Bochner measurable function $S_n\to F$.

Then it admits an approximation from nearly below: $$\|S_n(\omega)\|\leq \vartheta\|F(\omega)\|:\quad S_n\to F\quad(\vartheta>1)$$ (This is sufficient for most cases regarding proofs.)

Can it happen that it does not admit an approximation from below: $$\|S_n(\omega)\|\leq\|F(\omega)\|:\quad S_n\to F$$ (I'm just being curious wether it can actually fail.)

Constructions

The only constructions I found so far are cutoff to bound an approximation: $$E_n:=\{\|F_n\|\leq2\|F\|\}:\quad F'_n:=F_n\chi_{E_n}\implies\|F'_n\|\leq2\|F\|$$ and reset to obtain an increasing resp. decreasing approximation: $$R^\pm_n:=\{\|F_n\|\gtrless\|F'_{n-1}\|\}:\quad F'_n:=F_n\chi_{\Omega_n}+F'_{n-1}\chi_{\Omega_n^\complement}\implies\|F_n'\|\updownarrow\|F'_{n+1}\|$$ Apart from these truncation seems less relevant here: $$\Omega_n\uparrow\Omega:\quad F'_n:=\chi_{\Omega_n}\implies\|F'_n\|\uparrow\|F\|$$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

This is a modified version from: Cohn: Measure Theory

Enumerate a countable dense set: $$\#S\leq\mathfrak{n}:\quad S=\{s_1,\ldots\}\quad(\overline{S}=F\Omega)$$

Regard the finite subsets: $$S_K:=\{s_1,\ldots,s_K\}$$

Construct the domains by: $$A_k:=A_n(s_k):=\{\omega:\|s_k\|\leq\|F(\omega)\|\}\cap\{\omega:\|F(\omega)-s_k\|<\tfrac{1}{n}\}$$

And sum up their disjoint parts: $$A_k':=A_k\setminus\left(\bigcup_{l=1}^{k-1}A_l\right):\quad F_n:=\sum_{k=1}^{K=n}s_k\chi_{A_k'}$$ (Note that the supports are clearly measurable.)