Condition implying rationality of $u^n+v^n$

158 Views Asked by At

$Given :\ u+v \ is \ rational, \ u^2 + v^2 =1 \ , prove \ v^n + u^n \ is \ rational$.

What I have done so far is proving that $uv$ is rational by expanding $(u+v)^2$. I expanded $(u+v)^n$ using binomial expansion but I do not think this is the proper way.

Any hint about how to prove it please?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

2
On

From the given condition, $(u+v)^2=u^2+v^2+2uv=1+2uv$ is rational implies $uv$ is rational. $u^{n+2}+v^{n+2} = (u+v)(u^{n+1}+v^{n+1})-uv(u^n+v^n) $

since $u+v$ and $uv$ are rational, and the statement is true for $n=1,2$, $u^n+v^n$ is rational for all positive integers $n$ by induction.

4
On

Related to another answer and comment, but perhaps less "magic" and more motivated.

It is given that $u+v$ is rational, and you have proved that $uv$ is rational. By the binomial theorem, $$\eqalign{u^n+v^n &=(u+v)^n-\binom n1u^{n-1}v-\binom n2u^{n-2}v^2-\cdots -\binom n{n-2}u^2v^{n-2}-\binom n{n-1}uv^{n-1}\cr &=(u+v)^n-\binom n1(uv)(u^{n-2}+v^{n-2}) -\binom n2(uv)^2(u^{n-4}+v^{n-4})-\cdots\ .\cr}$$ Now every term on the RHS is either rational by what you know already, or can be assumed rational by induction.