Constant or Not?

232 Views Asked by At

Suppose I define $G(x)=\int_0^xf(t)dt$ as the area under the function $f(t)$ of which both $0$ and $x$ are within the domain of $f$, and $x$ can take any value within the domain.

Hence we can conclude $x$ is not a constant since it can take any values and also the area under the graph changes for different values of x.

Next, define $\int_0^bg(t)dt$ as the area under $g(t)$ such that $0$ and $b$ are within the domain of $g$, and $b$ is any constant value. (i.e it can be a $5$, a $13$, $\pi$, etc.)

I know that if $b$ is $5$, $13$, $\pi$ then $\int_0^5g(t)dt$, $\int_0^{13}g(t)dt$, $\int_0^{\pi}g(t)dt$ or the areas under these specific constants are constants. However my intuition tells me that since $b$ can take any constant values, $b$ itself isn't constant. Is this argument valid? Maybe it's because of my definition that $b$ can take any constant values that made it "not a constant". I know it is more than usual even in textbooks to assume $b$ in $\int_0^bf(t)dt$ is constant. And that, the author or the writer must have meant that "I'll give you a specific value, but I won't tell you what it is."

Because of this question I'm afraid I'm on the wrong path now towards learning mathematics. I'm a senior HS student (not living in US) planning to take an engineering degree, but my curiosity about the mathematics behind it especially calculus is like that of any aspiring mathematician.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Your question highlights a confusion that may arise when we do not distinguish between a variable or changing quantity, and an undetermined or unspecified constant quantity.

If a non-numerical symbol, say $ b, $ is called a constant, then it is to be understood as non-varying, only that the particular constant is not concretely or numerically specified or defined.

Essentially then, you're wondering whether an indeterminate constant isn't a variable. Well, strictly speaking they're not the same since one is defined as changing while the other is stable, but most people -- wrongly -- don't differentiate between them.

This is especially transparent when dealing with formal manipulations; it is necessary to differentiate between an indeterminate constant and a variable. This will guide our treatment towards the symbols and eliminate confusions. This is a context where differentiating between the two is not only useful, but logically necessary. Consider, for example, the polynomial in the indeterminate $ y $ -- now many would say in the variable $ y $ instead. While this makes no great visual difference, there is a great conceptual difference, and this is another reason why some confuse polynomials and functions defined by polynomials. They are not the same at all.