Criterion for proving that a quotient space is finite dimensional

466 Views Asked by At

In the book of Introductory Real Analysis of Kolmogorov and Fomin (page 122), there is some theorem about the dimension of quotient spaces. Let $L$ be vector space and $L'$ be a vector subspace. It says that $L/L'$ (the quotient space) is finite dimensional (with dimension $n$) if and only if any $x \in L$ can be written as:

$$x= \mu_1 x_1 + ... \mu_n x_n + y$$

where $x_i \notin L'$, $y \in L'$.

My question is then the following: Is this equivalent to saying that the quotient space is finite dimensional if and only if $L-L'$ (the complement of $L'$) is finite dimensional? It seems right but I am struggling proving it. Thanks!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

6
On BEST ANSWER

This is true depending on your definitions. If you mean the set theoretic complement $L-L'$, which is to say the set of all vectors $v \in L$ which are not in $L'$, then no. The set theoretic complement is not a vector subspace of $L$, and hence cannot be assigned a vector space dimension. If you mean a vector space complement of $L'$ in $L$, which is to say a subspace $L''$ of $L$ such that $L$ is the direct sum of $L'$ and $L''$, then this is true.

Note that it is really more correct to say a (vector space) complement of a subspace rather than the complement. This is because complements are far from unique. For example, if $L$ is the plane $\mathbb R^2$, and $L'$ is a one-dimensional subspace of $L$ (that is, a line passing through the origin), then every other line passing through the origin is a complement of $L'$ in $L$.

Anyway, if $L''$ is a complement of $L'$ in $L$, then $L''$ is isomorphic to the quotient vector space $L/L'$, an isomorphism being given by sending any $v \in L''$ to the coset $v + L'$ in $L/L'$. Hence $L/L'$ is finite dimensional if and only if $L''$ is.