Divergence proof problem in introductory analysis text.

37 Views Asked by At

The problem is this:

Show that if $a_n > 0$ and $\lim_{n\to \infty} na_n = L$ with $L \neq 0$, then the series $\sum a_n$ diverges. (from Abbott's Understanding Analysis, p. 68).

I want someone to correct my proof if it is wrong.

My proof:

Since $(\forall \epsilon >0)(\exists N\in \mathbb N)(\forall n\ge N)|na_n - L|<\epsilon$ is given, $(\forall n\ge N) L-\epsilon_0 < na_n < L+\epsilon_0$.

And assumed $N \neq 0$, $(\forall n \ge N) \frac{L-\epsilon_0}{n} < a_n < \frac{L+\epsilon_0}{n}$.

Then, let $\epsilon_0 = L - 1$. Then, we get $1/n < a_n < (2L-1)/n$.

Since $1/n < a_n$, by Comparison Test, $\sum a_n$ diverges.


Since the solution from the author is different from mine, I suspect whether there is a wrong step. I wasn't fully confident with defining e_0, but I have no idea whether it is correct or not.

Thank you!