Do users of RTL languages adopt an LTR standard for mathematics (in the same way they often do when using LTR words or phrases in RTL text)?

490 Views Asked by At

Non-mathematician here. There is a discussion on this forum titled "Is “applying similar operations from left to right” a convention or a rule that forces us to mark one answer wrong?" I found it trying to answer a question I have. I could not comment as I am new here (trolling protection I guess) My interest is software localisation. My question is whether mathematics is globally written Left to Right (LTR). i.e. do those substantial countries that use a RTL languages adopt an LTR standard for mathematics (in the same way they often do when using LTR words or phrases).

Note that I am not asking what is mathematically correct (i.e. use parenthesis properly) - I am asking what is commonly actually done? Thanks

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Most university-level math education has conformed to a left-to-right standard, regardless of how the native language is written. However, pre-university education differs, and it depends on the region.

For instance, see here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_Arabic_mathematical_notation.

One of the reasons for the predominance of left-to-right mathematical writing is that a majority of mathematical papers are written in left-to-right languages. Furthermore, it is difficult to find equivalent texts for some (advanced) topics written in a right-to-left sense. Even translation is particularly difficult. While there might be a translation for "limit" or "derivative" in some languages, there often isn't a direct translation for something like "cotangent bundle" or "Hom functor." How does one translate an advanced text when the nomenclature is so-far removed from the native language? (One may even argue that some of the nomenclature is pretty far removed from English, as well. "Eigenvector" is a horrible Frankenstein's monster of a word, grammatically speaking. And don't even get me started on "homomorphism" vs. "homeomorphism").

In fact, this phenomenon has led to English becoming almost mandatory for university-level technical education in many countries.

4
On

Just put in some parentheses, and then you don't have to worry about the LTR-vs-RTL issue. The expression $(a-b)-c$ means the same thing everywhere.