Does every finite nontrivial group have two distinct irreducible representation of equal degree?

401 Views Asked by At

To Prove the statement

non-trivial group has at least two distinct representations with degree 1.

I would like to use induction. Also I have the relation $$|G|=\sum_{k=1}^{n} d_k^2$$, where n stands for degree of irreducible representation and $d_k$ stands for degree of $k$th representation.

Since G is not trivial, so suppose $|G|=2$, then clearly we have $2=1^2+1^2$ is the only possibility.

Suppose ture for $|G| = m$, then $$|G|=\sum_{k=1}^{n} d_k^2 = 1+1+ \sum_{k=3}^{n} d_k^2$$

Now if $|G|=m+1$, then $$|G|=1+1+1+\sum_{k=3}^{n} d_k^2$$, where the 3=1+1+1 is the only possibility.

Therefore, I think I finished my proof by induction. However, I am not confident with this proof...I am thinking if I misunderstood something or missed some crucial parts?

Could someone help me to check this proof? Or provide me some hints to prove the statement in different way.

Thanks in advance!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

If water is wet then snow is hot. If grass is green then pandas are red. If this is a math site then Siddhārtha Gautama is the President of the United States. In the implication "If X then Y," you can't just set X and Y to be any two claims you want! The claim Y has to logically follow from claim X for some reason.

In your "If X then Y" implication, you set X to be the claim "groups of order $m$ have two distinct one-dimensional representations" and Y to be the same claim but for $m+1$. But why in the world do you think that a group of order $m+1$ would have two distinct one-dimensional representations just because groups of order $m$ do? You can't just make stuff up.

Induction wouldn't really be the way to go, because generally groups of order $m$ and $m+1$ don't have anything to do with each other any more than the prime factorizations of $m$ and $m+1$.

In fact, the claim that you're trying to prove

[Every] non-trivial [finite] group has at least two distinct representations with degree 1

is false.

If $G$ is any nonabelian finite simple group, then a nontrivial representation $G\to\mathrm{GL}_1(\mathbb{C})$ must have a kernel smaller than $G$, but since $G$ has no proper nontrivial normal subgroups and the kernel is normal, the kernel must be $1$, so by the first isomorphism theorem $G$ is isomorphic to a subgroup of $\mathrm{GL}_1(\mathbb{C})$, but $\mathrm{GL}_1(\mathbb{C})$ is abelian and subgroups of abelian groups are abelian hence $G$ is abelian, a contradiction.

The question in your title,

Does every finite nontrivial group have two distinct irreducible representation of equal degree?

is a different question. The answer is yes. This MathOverflow thread discusses this exact question. The proof seems to depend on the CFSG (classification of finite simple groups), so is pretty hard.