Double induction with a constraint

100 Views Asked by At

If I want to do a mathematical double induction on $n$ and $t$ where $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $1 \leqslant t \leqslant n$ then obviously the base step is $P(n=1,t=1)$ but how do I implement the induction hypothesis. Im very confused as I can’t assume $P(n,t+1)$ to be true nor $P(n+1, t)$ to be true either as I don’t know whether $t+1>n$ or not.

What statements should I then assume and which statement should I prove in the inductive step?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

3
On

This is going to depend a lot on exactly what you're trying to prove, but here is a general idea for an inductive approach:

Let $Q(n)$ be the statement "$P(n,t)$ for all $t$ between $1$ and $n$", and prove that $Q$ is satisfied for all natural numbers using induction. In each inductive step, you can again use induction: prove $P(n,t+1)$ from assuming both $Q(n-1)$ and $P(n,t)$.

7
On

There are different solutions possible, depending on your exact problem.

  • The first one, which probably works, but is not elegant at all is to prove by induction on $n$ the property $\forall 1\leq t\leq n, P(n,t)$. You would prove the base step by setting $n=1$ which forces $t=1$, and for the induction case, you suppose the property for $n$, and prove by induction on $t$ that for all $1\leq t\leq n+1$, you have $P(n+1,t)$. Note that you have to adapt this method to your case, so that you can reduce your problem to a subproblem in the induction step.

  • The second solution I can think of, which might not be applicable, but is worth trying, is to try and reduce it to a single induction. For that you can try and find a combination of $n$ and $t$ (say $n+t$ for instance) such that $P(n,t)$ with $n+t = k$ implies $P(n',t')$ with $n'+t' = k+1$, and you can then perform the induction on $k$.

These are very generic, and without any more precisions, I can't give you a more specific answer