Exercise with $u$-substitution

65 Views Asked by At

How would I "see" this or go a head to solve it?

I just can't understand it or see why I would go that way; how can I make myself able to see stuff like this?

$$\int \frac{t}{ \sqrt{4-t^4}}dt $$

Answer will be that I substitute $t^2 = u$ and then work from there on out, but how would I ever see it that specific?

3

There are 3 best solutions below

0
On

With practice, you'll develop the intuition you seek. Picking $u = t^2$ is very helpful here, because $$u = t^2 \implies du = 2t\,dt \iff t\,dt = \dfrac {du}{2}$$

Note that we have $\frac 12du = t\,dt $ in the numerator!

Thus, the integral, after substitution, becomes $$\frac 12\int \frac{ du}{\sqrt {4-u^2}}$$

Now, it's just a matter of using trig substitution $u =2 \sin \theta$.

0
On

The idea is to reverse the chain rule. If you have $$\int \frac{t}{ \sqrt{4-t^4}}dt,$$ for example, you're motivated to take $u = t^2$ because of the $t$ in the numerator. Then $du = 2t \ dt$, and you almost have it! Making a substitution when the derivative of the object is sitting near is usually works, for example:

  1. $\int \frac{1}{t \ln t} \ dt$, $u = \ln t$
  2. $\int \sin x \ \cos x \, dx$, $u = \sin x$
  3. $\int -\sin x \ e^{\cos x} \ dx$, $u = \cos x$
  4. $\int 2t \sin(t^2) \ dt$, $u = t^2$

etc.

0
On

If you make a substitution $u = f(t)$, then $du = f'(t) \,dt$, so we can view a choice of substitution as a choice of which factor of the integrand to pair with $dt$, that is, what to take as $f'(t)$; then we can recover what $u$ is by integrating. Essentially your only choices are $\frac{1}{\sqrt{4 - t^4}}$, which looks no easier to integrate than the integrand at hand (and in fact is much harder) and $t$. By elimination, we take $$du = 2 t \,dt$$ so that $$u = t^2.$$ (Here, we've harmlessly introduced a factor of $2$ to prevent the unnecessary appearance of fractional expressions after the substitution---if this isn't apparent, try substituting $u = \frac{1}{2} t^2$, $du = t \,dt$ and see what happens.)

Like you say, with this substitution in hand, the integral becomes $$\int \frac{t \, dt}{\sqrt{4 - t^4}} = \frac{1}{2} \int \frac{du}{\sqrt{4 - u^2}},$$ which can be handled with a standard trigonometric substitution.