Existence of solution of Congruence based on Exponent

112 Views Asked by At

What is the general approach of proving existence of integer solution of congruence based on its exponent? For example, if $x, y, z$ are all arbitrary odd number, then
$43^x + 102^y \equiv 35^z \pmod {120}$ has no integer solution, how can I prove this? what are the approaches?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

3
On

Note:

$43^{2k+1}\equiv 43$ or $67 \mod 120$


added in response to inquiry in comment:

because $43^1=43, $

$43^2=1829=15\times120+49\equiv49,$

$43^3\equiv43\times49=2107=17\times120+67\equiv67, $

and $43^4\equiv49^2=2401=20\times120+1\equiv1\pmod{120}$


$102^{2l+1}\equiv 102$ or $48$ or $72 \mod 120$

$35^{2m+1}\equiv 35\mod120$

1
On

A first step would be to apply the Chinese remainder theorem. Because $120=2^3\times3\times5$ the problem reduces to solving the system of congquences \begin{eqnarray*} 43^x + 102^y \equiv 35^z \pmod {2^3},\\ 43^x + 102^y \equiv 35^z \pmod {3\hphantom{^3}},\\ 43^x + 102^y \equiv 35^z \pmod {5\hphantom{^3}}. \end{eqnarray*} Of course then we can reduce the bases to get the equivalent system \begin{eqnarray*} 3^x + 6^y \equiv 3^z \pmod {2^3},\\ 1^x + 0^y \equiv 2^z \pmod {3\hphantom{^3}},\\ 3^x + 2^y \equiv 0^z \pmod {5\hphantom{^3}}. \end{eqnarray*} Next you can list the different values of these powers, where the powers mod $p^k$ cycle with a period dividing $\varphi(p^k)=p^{k-1}(p-1)$ or eventually become $0$. For example:

  • The first congruence shows that if $y\geq3$ then $x\equiv z\pmod{2}$.
  • The second congruence shows that $z\equiv0\pmod{2}$.
  • The third congruence shows that $x\equiv y\pmod{2}$.

As you require $x$, $y$ and $z$ to be all odd, the second observation shows that there are no such solutions.