Find all the partitions of the set of integers which are compatible with the usual law of addition

97 Views Asked by At

This question comes from problem 8.13 (b) of chapter 2 of Artin's Algebra (2nd edition).

By compatible, it means that:

Let $S$ be a set with a law of composition (i.e. a binary operation). A partition $P$ of $S$ is compatible with the law of composition if for every $i$ and $j$, there exists $k$ such that $$\Pi_i\Pi_j\subset\Pi_k$$ where $\Pi_i,\Pi_j,\Pi_k\in P$ and the product set $\Pi_i\Pi_j=\{ab\mid a\in\Pi_i,b\in\Pi_j\}$.

I can see that:

  1. The partition $P=\{\{n\}\mid n\in\mathbb{Z}\}$ is compatible with the usual addition $+$.

  2. For any $n\in\mathbb{Z^+}$, $\mathbb{Z}/n\mathbb{Z}$ (i.e. the integers modulo $n$) is a partition of $\mathbb{Z}$ that is compatible with the usual addition $+$.

Could anyone please give me some hint on how to prove that there exists no other partition which is compatible with $+$? (or if there is, how could one find all of them?)

Thanks in advance!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Fun exercise. I hope you've given it a good try yourself. As a hint, try to show the block containing $0$ is a subgroup. A complete solution is below.


I assume you're letting $(S, \circ) = (\mathbb{Z}, +)$. I'll write $\Pi_i + \Pi_j$ additively to avoid confusion.

Say $\Pi_0$ contains $0$. Then $\Pi_j \subset \Pi_0 + \Pi_j \subset \Pi_k$, forcing $j=k$ and $\Pi_j = \Pi_0 + \Pi_j$ for all $j$. In particular, $\Pi_0 = \Pi_0 + \Pi_0$, so $\Pi_0$ is closed under sums.

Now suppose $n \in \Pi_i$ and $-n \in \Pi_j$. Then $0 \in \Pi_i + \Pi_j \subset \Pi_k$, forcing $\Pi_k = \Pi_0$ and $\Pi_i + \Pi_j = \Pi_0$. When $i=0$, this says $\Pi_0 = \Pi_0 + \Pi_j \supset \Pi_j$, so $-n \in \Pi_0$ and $\Pi_0$ is closed under inverses.

Hence $\Pi_0$ is a subgroup. Thus $\Pi_0 = m\mathbb{Z}$ for some fixed $m \in \mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0}$.

Suppose $m=0$. If $\Pi_i$ contained more than 1 element, the above equation $\Pi_i + \Pi_j = \Pi_0$ furnishes a contradiction, so each $\Pi_i$ is a singleton and we're in your first case.

Now suppose $m>0$. Suppose $n \in \Pi_j$. Then $\Pi_j = m\mathbb{Z} + \Pi_j \supset n + m\mathbb{Z}$. Hence the congruence classes $n + m\mathbb{Z}$ for $0 \leq n < m$ are each contained in some $\Pi_j$, so the partition must be obtained by taking unions of congruence classes. But now suppose $\Pi_i$ were the union of at least two congruence classes. Then the equation $\Pi_i + \Pi_j = \Pi_0$ again furnishes a contradiction since $\Pi_0$ is only a single congruence class.

So there are indeed no more.