Find the equation for the angle in which the particle abandons the hemicircle. No friction.

123 Views Asked by At

I think I missed something in this mechanics problem.

We're given a polish and homogeneous hemicircle which has mass $M$ and a particle of mass $m$ laying on the top of it.enter image description here

There is also no friction between the hemicircle and the ground. Find the equation for the angle $\theta$ in which the particle abandons the hemicircle surface.

I can't find my mistake.

As we have no external horizontal forces acting on the system particle + hemicircle we must have conservation of the horizontal position of the center of mass.

I made this horrible drawing to try to understand the movement:

enter image description here

we would have $x = \frac{mR \sin(\theta)}{M+m}$, making $M = k \cdot m \iff k = \frac M m$, we would have:

$$x = \frac{R \sin(\theta)}{1+k} \implies \dot x = \frac{R \dot \theta \cos(\theta)}{1+k}$$

from this, I found that the velocity of the particle with respect to the ground was:

$$R \dot \theta (\cos (\theta)(\frac k{k+1})u_x - \sin (\theta) u_y) = \vec v_P $$

And conservation of energy

$$mgR = mgR\cos(\theta) + \frac{mv_P^2+ M \dot x^2}2$$

gave me:

$$2\frac gR(1-\cos(\theta))(1+k) = \dot \theta^2 [\sin^2(\theta) +k]$$

Finally, I used the abandonment equation: $\frac gR \cos(\theta) = \dot \theta^2$

Which led me to:

$$3 \cos(\theta) - \frac{\cos^3(\theta)}{1+k} = 2$$

but I feel something is wrong because $k=0$ should give me $\cos(\theta) = \frac23$ any insights on my mistakes?

EDIT: I think on the line of the energy conservation the term $\sin^2(\theta)$ is the one causing trouble. I'm very confident about the expression for the velocity of the particle.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

Hint.

Assuming that the movement occurs into a maximum declivity plane, and calling $A$ the semi-sphere center and $B$ the $m$ mass position, we have

$$ B = A + R(\sin\theta,\cos\theta) $$

then $\dot B = \dot A + R(\cos\theta,-\sin\theta)\dot\theta$ so the lagrangian can be established as

$$ L = \frac 12 m \|\dot B\|^2+\frac 12 M\|\dot A\|^2-m g R\cos\theta $$

with $A = (a,0)$ and the movement equations (while in contact) are

$$ \left\{ \begin{array}{rcl} \ddot a& =& \frac{m \sin (\theta) \left(R \dot\theta^2-g \cos (\theta)\right)}{M+m-m \cos ^2(\theta)} \\ \ddot\theta&=&\frac{\sin (\theta) \left(m R \dot\theta^2 \cos (\theta )-g (m+M)\right)}{m R \cos ^2(\theta)-R (m+M)} \\ \end{array} \right. $$