Finding the ratio $\dfrac{\Delta E_X}{\Delta E_Y}$

65 Views Asked by At

enter image description here

These two cylinders are put on top. Once we heat them with an amount of $\Delta T$, the gravitational potential energy of $X$ and $Y$ are increasing by $\Delta E_X$ and $\Delta E_Y$ . Find the ratio $\dfrac{\Delta E_X}{\Delta E_Y}$

I tried to find their potential energy

$$U_X = mgh \tag{1}$$

and

$$U_Y = mg(2h) = 2mgh \tag {2}$$

However, there should be something I'm missing.

Regards!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

Yes, so see. Sorry for my presentation skills.

If you heat the boxes with temperature $T$, they expand - and the expansion of each of them is proportional to their lengths and the change in temperature.

So as the lengths are same, they both will expand by the same amount.

Let's say each of them expands by length $l$.

So the COM of lower one goes higher by $\dfrac l2$, and the COM of upper one goes higher by $\dfrac l2+l = \dfrac{3l}{2}$

Since the density of the rods is still same, we can calculate the Potential difference directly by mgh (h of COM)

delta $E($upper rod$) = m\cdot g\cdot\left(\dfrac{3l}{2}\right)$

delta $E($lower rod$) = m\cdot g\cdot\dfrac l2$

Ratio $= \dfrac13$