General identification of Zariski tangent space with space of derivations

360 Views Asked by At

I'm reading through Schlessinger's Functors of Artin Rings to get background on Schlessinger's Theorem. The notion of a tangent space is critical in the argument, but I do not have enough intuition for it yet.

Let $\Lambda$ be a complete noetherian local ring with maximal ideal $\mu$ and residue field $k$. We work over the category $\mathbf{C}$ of artinian local $\Lambda$-algebras with residue field $k$, and the category $\hat{\mathbf{C}}$ of complete noetherian local $\Lambda$-algebras $A$ such that the quotients by a power of the maximal ideal $A/\mathfrak{m}^n$ all lie in $\mathbf{C}$.

Schlessinger defines the Zariski cotangent space of $A \in \hat{\mathbf{C}}$ as the $k$-vector space $t_A^{*} = \mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A)$ with the Zariski tangent space $t_A$ being the dual $k$-vector space to $t_A$. He then claims that "by a simple calculation" we may identify $t_A$ with the space $\operatorname{Der}_{\Lambda}(A, k)$ of $\Lambda$-linear derivations from $A$ to $k$ (treating $k$ as an $A$-module).

I understand how this identification works in more familiar cases. For example, if $\Lambda = \mathbb{C}$ and $A = \mathbb{C}[[X_1, \dots, X_n]]$, then $t_A^{*}$ may be realized as the $n$-dimensional space spanned by $X_1, \dots, X_n$, and an element $\varphi$ of the tangent space is determined by the image $\alpha_i = \varphi(X_i)$ of each of these variables in $\mathbb{C}$. The derivation corresponding to this element is given by $$a = a_0 + \sum_{i = 1}^n a_{1,i} X_i + \dots \mapsto \sum_{i = 1}^n \alpha_i a_{1, i}.$$

I'm having trouble with how this construction would generalize to arbitrary complete noetherian local $\Lambda$-algebras; is there a canonical way of finding the "$t_A^{*}$-component" of $A$ using the hypotheses on $A \in \hat{\mathbf{C}}$, analogous to taking the linear terms in the example above?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Here is an elementary argument. We want to find a perfect pairing of $k$-vector spaces $$ \mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A) \times \mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(A,k) \to k $$ or equivalently, a $\Lambda$-linear pairing $$ \mathfrak{m} \times \mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(A,k) \to k $$ with trivial right kernel and left kernel equal to $\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A$.

The pairing is evaluation of a derivation on an element of $\mathfrak{m}$: $$ (x, \partial) \mapsto \partial(x) \in k. $$ Note first that by assumption, the natural map $\Lambda \to A$ induces an isomorphism $\Lambda/\mu \to A/\mathfrak{m}$. In particular, every element of $A$ can be written as $r + x$ where $r$ is in the image of $\Lambda \to A$ and $x \in \mathfrak{m}$.

Suppose now that $\partial$ is a derivation such that $\partial(x) = 0$ for all $x \in \mathfrak{m}$. Then $\partial(r + x) = \partial(r) + \partial(x) = 0$ since $\partial$ is $\Lambda$-linear and so $\partial$ is the $0$ derivation. This proves that the right kernel of the pairing is zero.

Next note that both $\mathfrak{m}$ and $\mu$ act by $0$ on $k$. Therefore, by Leibniz rule and $\Lambda$-linearity, $\partial(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A) = 0$ for all derivations $\partial$. Thus the pairing factors through a pairing $$ \mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A) \times \mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(A,k) \to k. $$

To conclude that this pairing is perfect, we need to show that for any nonzero $x$ in $\mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A)$, there exists a derivation $\partial$ with $\partial(x) \neq 0$. Let $$ \bar{A} = A/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A) $$ and denote by $\bar{\mathfrak{m}} = \mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A)$. Then composition with the surjection $A \to \bar{A}$ induces a bijection $\mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(\bar{A},k) \to \mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(A,k)$.

Now $\bar{A}$ is a local Artinian $k$-algebra with maximal ideal $\bar{\mathfrak{m}}$ satisfying that $\bar{\mathfrak{m}}^2 = 0$. Then $\mathrm{Der}_\Lambda(\bar{A},k) = \mathrm{Der}_k(\bar{A},k)$ and we can identify our pairing with the same pairing for $\bar{A}$ as a $k$-algebra, namely $$ \bar{\mathfrak{m}} \times \mathrm{Der}_k(\bar{A},k) \to k $$ and now this is the familiar setting where we can check the pairing is perfect by hand, e.g. by picking a splitting $\bar{A} = k \oplus \bar{\mathfrak{m}}$ as vector spaces.

I should note that $\mathfrak{m}/(\mathfrak{m}^2 + \mu A)$ is the relative Zariski cotangent space for the map of schemes $\mathrm{Spec} A \to \mathrm{Spec} \Lambda$ and the above result is true more generally for any morphism of schemes $f : X \to S$. This is proved using more sophisticated ideas in the Stacks Project.