Given that $18|n^3$, can we conclude $18|n^2$?

110 Views Asked by At

Given that $18|n^3$, can we conclude $18|n^2$?

I have been working on this a lot, and so far I have determined from the prime factorization of $18$, that $2|n$ and $3|n$. Therefore we also know $6|n$. I am not sure how to use this however to show that $18|n^2$.

Could we say that since $6|n$, $36|n^2$, or is this an inaccurate claim?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Write $n=p_1p_2\cdots p_k$, where the $p_i$ are prime (there might be some repetitions). Then $n^3=p_1^3p_2^3\cdots p_k^3$. If $18=3^2\cdot 2$ divides $n^3$, then at least one of the $p_i$ is equal to $3$ and one is equal to $2$, so reordering we may assume $p_1=2$ and $p_2=3$. But then $n^2=p_1^2p_2^2\cdots p_k^2=2\cdot 18 p_3^2\cdots p_k^2$ is divisible by $18$.

You can generalize this to prove the following fact: Suppose that $m$ and $n$ and $k$ such that:

  1. the powers of the distinct primes appearing in the prime decomposition of $m$ are all at most $k$;
  2. $m$ divides $n^l$ for some $l\geq k$.

Then $m$ divides $n^k$.