Hatcher's proof of Van Kampen Theorem

689 Views Asked by At

I am studying Van Kampen Theorem using Hatcher's textbook. I am dealing with the general statement, I mean: (pg 43)

enter image description here

He defines previously the free product of groups (pg 41) as:

enter image description here

I can follow the main idea of the proof but I don't understand how he can say (pg 45):

enter image description here

By definition, elements of the free product should be reduced words, am I right? Then he should not be considering unreduced words in a free product, since there won't be none. I suppose I have missed something, if that is the case and I am pretty sure that it is, Where I am misunderstanding?

Thanks in advance!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

The author might need to consider unreduced words in order to simplify the presentation of the proof. So while, technically speaking, it is slight abuse of language to say that these unreduced words live in the free product, one may extend the map $\Phi$ to these words by reducing them first and then applying the original $\Phi$.