Homework problem for a first grader on $9$gag

698 Views Asked by At

I saw the below image on 9gag. And naturally I asked myself how many patterns can one find (and justify)? Are there any "fun" patterns, using your "first grader imagination" and your mathematical skills?

enter image description here

7

There are 7 best solutions below

3
On

I guess it is is $J = 14$. Indeed, the sum of the diagonal GBS is $40$. If you add $J$, then also the sum of the other diagonal (JBP) is $40$.

Edited

18
On

J makes sense for a firstgrader

this way both diagonals are 40

I don't think such tasks are helpful in any way.

0
On

For instance $23=2\cdot 6 + 11$ so with $?=8$ we would have $8+2\cdot 6=20$.

And $23-11-6=6$ and $20-6-8=6$ so $?=8$ could work out this way as well.

0
On

The digits of $23$ sum to $5$, and $6 + 5 = 11$. The digits of $20$ sum to $2$, so one answer is $8 = D$.

1
On

$23 \times 6 \times 11 = 1518$

$20 \times 6 \times \left(12 + \frac{13}{20}\right) = 1518$

Thus, the answer is $\left(\text{H} + \frac{\text{I}}{\text{P}}\right)$

0
On

Both diagonals summed is 20, Blank => J = 14.

Top and bot row, subtracted left to right. 2(23-20)=6. 2(J-11)=6. J = 14 again.

0
On

The answer J doesn't seem as indefensible to me as the question implies.

Plugging these numbers in makes the two diagonal sums match, as others have pointed out. However, it also makes the two horizontal differences match (J-G=3, and S-O=3) and the two vertical differences match (S-J=9, O-G=9).

That's three patterns all satisfied by one number, which is pretty pattern-y from non-mathematician's point of view.

I do agree that it doesn't seem to have much pedagogical value as an exercise for small children.