How can the same equation have two different partial derivatives with respect to the same variable?

68 Views Asked by At

It would help if someone can explain to me what I read in my book.

The equation is $x=rcos\theta$. We want to find $\frac{\partial r}{\partial x}$. One way to find it is to leave the equation as is and find $\frac{\partial x}{\partial r}$, which is $cos\theta$ and take the reciprocal of that to get $\frac{1}{cos\theta}$. The other way is to tweak the equation to be $r=\frac{x}{cos\theta}$ and find $\frac{\partial r}{\partial x}$ straight away and get $\frac{1}{cos\theta}$.

But then, here is where I get confused. The author says because we know $r=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}$, we can then find $\frac{\partial r}{\partial x}=\frac{x}{\sqrt{x^2+y^2}}=\frac{x}{r}=cos\theta$. The author explains the reason we are getting this answer is because here, instead of holding $\theta$ constant, we are pre-supposing $y$ to be constant and when $x$ varies, both $\theta$ and $r$ vary. Finally because this is not partial derivative by its definition, $cos\theta$ is rejected as a answer.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Note the following general principle: In an $n$-dimensional environment you can only talk about partial derivatives after a full set of $n$ independent variables (coordinate functions) has been specified.

In the case of the $(x,y)$-plane with additional "coordinate variables" $r$ and $\theta$ into the game you can consider, e.g., $x$ and $y$ as your "free" variables. Then any function $u$ defined in the plane, in particular $r$ and $\theta$, has well defined partial derivatives ${\partial u\over\partial x}$ and ${\partial u\over\partial y}$. One obtains $${\partial r\over\partial x}={2x\over\sqrt{x^2+y^2}}={x\over r},\qquad {\partial r\over\partial y}={2y\over\sqrt{x^2+y^2}}={y\over r}\ ,$$ and $${\partial\theta\over\partial x}={-y\over x^2+y^2},\qquad {\partial\theta\over\partial y}={x\over x^2+y^2}\ .$$ If you adopt $r$ and $\theta$ as your "free" variables then you obtain from $x=r\cos\theta$, $y=r\sin\theta$ that $${\partial x\over\partial r}=\cos\theta,\quad{\partial x\over\partial\theta}=-r\sin\theta,\quad\ldots\ .$$