How to subtruct countable sequence from countable sequence

30 Views Asked by At

In a classic proof that the set of sequence points together with its limit is compact, we use the statement that any neighbourhood of a limit point contains infinite number of sequence points, hence we need only finite number of open sets to cover the rest of the sequence. That is, we state,, that countable minus countable is finite. On the other hand, if we subtract from countable set of natural numbers all odd numbers, then the set of all even numbers is countable. Thus, countable minus countable is countable. How to deal with cardinality in this case? What am I missing? Marina

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

Any neighborhood of a limit point contains all but finitely many of the points of the sequence. That is a stronger condition than containing infinitely many points of the sequence, which is what makes an accumulation point. Once you say all but finitely many it is clear that we need only finitely many open sets to cover the rest. You are correct that deleting a countable infinity from a countably infinite set can leave none, finitely many, or countably infinitely many.