if 2 compact manifolds has infinity intersection, is there any point such that the tangent space of this point are equals?

122 Views Asked by At

This question came from more specific question, that I am trying to solve with the above statement.

The specific question is : Given $M_1, M_2$ in $\mathbb{R}^3$ , smooth compact manifolds, while $M_1$ is 1-dimensional and $M_2$ is 2-dimensional. Assuming that $M_1 \cap M_2$ is infinity prove that there exists $x \in M_1 \cap M_2$ such that $TxM_1 \subset TxM_2$.

I managed to prove existence of x, such for any neighborhood of x, $Ux$.

$M_1 \cap M_2 \cap Ux \neq \{x\}$ , aka for any neighborhood of x, there is point $y$, such that $ x \neq y \in M_1 \cap M_2 \cap Ux$. could not get any further.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

7
On BEST ANSWER

If $x \in M_1 \cap M_2$ is such that $T_xM_1 \oplus T_x M_2 = T_x \Bbb R^3$ then there is a neighborhood $U$ of $x$ such that $M_1 \cap U \cap M_2 = \{x\}$. Since $M_1$ is compact it follows that there is only finitely many such $x$.

(Notice that compactness of $M_2$ is not needed.)

Why there is such a neighborhood ? There a neighborhood $V \ni x$ with local coordinates $a,b,c$ around $x$ such that $M_2 \cap V = \{(a,b,c) \mid c = 0 \}$. Consider a parametrization of $M_1$ given by $\gamma(t) = (a(t),b(t), c(t))$, with $\gamma(0) = x$. On has $c(0) = 0$ by hypothesis, and since $T_xM_1 + T_xM_2 = T_x \Bbb R^3$ we should have $c'(0) \neq 0$. In particular, for $ t> 0$ small enough, $c(t) \neq 0$ so $\gamma(t) \cap M_2 = \emptyset$ and it follows that there is a neighborhood $U \ni x$ with $M_1 \cap M_2 \cap U = \{x\}$.