If $a < b$ and $b = \infty$, then $a < \infty$?

108 Views Asked by At

A very simple question, but I am not sure for this moment.

I have a strict inequality $a < b$. And I prove that $b = \infty$, say $b$ is an integral. Does this prove that $a < \infty$, that is, $a$ is finite? Question seems simple but things can easily be messed up with infinity.

To be more clear, say $a = \int f dx$ and $b = \int g dx$ and I have $a < b$. If $\int g dx = \infty$, can we say that $\int f dx < \infty$?

If one can construct pathological counterexamples involve limits etc, I will be very happy.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Talking about $\int fdx$ makes no sense, as that is a concrete function, and not a number.

You might want to talk about the definite integral, $\int_0^\infty fdx$ and $\int_0^\infty gdx$. You may also want to discern between showing $\int_0^\infty fdx<\int_0^\infty gdx$ (in which case your claim would be correct), and the case where $f(x)<g(x)$ for all $x$ in the domain over which you are integrating.

In the latter case take $f(x)=1$ and $g(x)=2$.