Implicit differentiation of "similar" functions

55 Views Asked by At

The graph of the equation $x^2 + y^2 = 1$ gives a circle of radius $1$, centered at the origin:

enter image description here

After we find its derivative: $$ \frac{dy}{dx} (x^2 + y^2) = \frac{dy}{dx} 1 \\ 2x + 2y \frac{dy}{dx} = 0 \\ \frac{dy}{dx} = -\frac{x}{y} $$ if we graph it on a 3D space we get this shape: enter image description here and it does describe the slope of the circle (positive in quadrant II & IV, negative in I & III)

Now let's consider a "similar" equation: $$ x^3 + xy^2 = x $$ The graph should be same everywhere except when $x = 0$, since it's just the last equation multiplied by $x$ on both sides, and the differentiability of it should be the same except at $x = 0$

enter image description here

However, if we work out the derivative of y with respect to x: $$ \frac{dy}{dx} (x^3 + xy^2) = \frac{dy}{dx} x \\ 3x^2 + y^2 + 2xy \frac{dy}{dx} = 1 \\ \frac{dy}{dx} = -\frac{3x^2+y^2-1}{2xy} $$ we get a completely different function, and plotting the graph yields this weird shape: enter image description here and it doesn't describe the slope of the circle at all. So why does finding the derivative of the first equation works, but not the second?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

The only difference between the two derivatives is entirely due to the introduction of the vertical line $ \ x = 0 \ $ that is combined with the circle. The derivative for the second "curve" is $$ \frac{dy}{dx} \ \ = \ \ \frac{1 \ - \ 3x^2 \ - \ y^2 }{2xy} \ \ = \ \ \frac{(\overbrace{1 \ - \ x^2 \ - \ y^2}^{= \ 0}) \ - \ 2x^2 }{2xy} \ \ = \ \ -\frac{ x^2 }{ xy} \ \ . $$

For points on the circle that are not on the $ \ y-$axis, both derivative expressions produce the same result: for example, at $ \ ( -\frac45 \ , \ \frac35 ) \ , $ we have $$ \frac{dy}{dx} \ \ = \ \ -\frac{-\frac45}{\frac35} \ \ = \ \ \frac43 \ \ \ \ \text{versus} \ \ \ \frac{dy}{dx} \ \ = \ \ \frac{1 \ - \ 3·\frac{16}{25} \ - \ \frac{9}{25} }{2·\left(-\frac45 \right) ·\frac35} \ \ = \ \ -\frac{\frac{ - 32}{25} }{\frac{24}{25}} \ \ = \ \ \frac43 \ \ . $$

For the circle, we simply find horizontal tangents at $ \ (0 \ , \ \pm 1) \ \ , $ while $ \ x^3 + xy^2 \ = \ x \ \ $ has an indeterminate "value" $ \ -\frac{ 0^2 }{ 0·y} \ $ at all the points on the $ \ y-$axis [it is ambiguous at $ \ (0 \ , \ \pm 1) \ \ $ because there are both horizontal and vertical tangents at those points].