In how many different ways can $7$ identical objects be distributed between $3$ ordered boxes?

110 Views Asked by At

Why is this a permutation and not a combination?

I have the solution for the following question. The problem I am experiencing is I do not understand how the answer is found.

The question as follows:

In how many different ways can $7$ identical objects be distributed between $3$ ordered boxes, box 1, box 2 and box 3? For how many of these distributions is there at least one object in each box?

The solution I have finds the following first: $$\binom92 = 36$$

However, when I put this into the calculator I get an answer of $18$

The final answer is: $$\binom62 = 15$$

When I also put the above into the calculator I get $12$...

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

The solutions are correct and the numbers you got are not that of the corresponding $^nP_r$ since generally $^nP_r\ge \ ^nC_r$. It seems like you got $$9\times2=18$$and$$6\times2=12$$ instead of the correct answers.

Note that $$\binom{n}{r}=\frac{n!}{r!(n-r)!}$$