In valued fields (of rank > 1), is the p-adic completion of the algebraic closure still algebraically closed?

169 Views Asked by At

Let $K$ be a valued field and assume its valuation ring $\mathcal{O}_K$ is $p$-adically separated. If we assume further that $K$ is algebraically closed and we take the $p$-adic completion, is the result algebraically closed?

I know many places where this is asserted for rank 1 valuations, and as far as I can tell the "usual" proof works basically the same way in the more general case. For example, I think the proof in these notes by Brian Conrad http://math.stanford.edu/~conrad/248APage/handouts/algclosurecomp.pdf works the same, as long as you replace the absolute values by valuations and replace things like $\frac{1}{j}$ with something like $v(p^j)$. I've looked briefly through Bourbaki's Commutative Algebra and Zariski-Samuel's book and haven't seen this fact; those references seem so comprehensive I'm nervous that the result is not true and I am missing something.

Thanks very much for any help! Best would be a reference I can use, but I'd also be happy with someone reassuring me this result I want is correct. I'd also be happy to know if there is a more natural way to phrase it than how I've phrased it (in terms of a valuation ring being $p$-adically separated).


Here are a few additional comments. I think I have written up a proof of algebraic closedness, but I would still be reassured if someone can tell me this is a well-known fact.

Thanks @Lubin for your comment! I don't know what the most standard example of a valuation ring of rank > 1 is. The example I feel like I understand the best is the following. Let $k$ be a perfect valued field of characteristic $p$ and rank 1. (I picture something like $k = \mathbb{F}_p((t^{1/p^{\infty}}))$ with the $t$-adic valuation.) Then take the $p$-typical Witt vectors $W(k)$ and let $K = W(k)[1/p]$. I believe then you can put a rank 2 valuation on this field with value group $\mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{R}$ with the lexicographic ordering, where the first entry corresponds to the $p$-adic valuation and where the second entry corresponds to the $t$-adic valuation. The corresponding valuation ring is similar to an example in Remark 4.6 from these notes from a course taught by Bhargav Bhatt www-personal.umich.edu/~stevmatt/perfectoid2.pdf It includes elements like $p(1/[t])$ and $[t]$ but not $1/[t]$. I'm afraid I don't have an algebraically closed example if that's what you wanted... the best I could say would be take the algebraic closure of the example I just gave.

Because I said the valuation ring was $p$-adically separated, I'm pretty sure the $p$-adic completion is the same as the "usual" completion of a valued field... Explicitly I'd want the completion to consist of $p$-adic Cauchy sequences $(x_1, x_2, x_3, \ldots)$, where for every $j > 0$, there exists an $N > 0$ such that if $n_1, n_2 > N$, we have $x_{n_1} - x_{n_2} \in p^j \mathcal{O}_K$.