Inequality with four positive integers looking for upper bound

232 Views Asked by At

Umm. This comes from Diophantine quartic equation in four variables and will finish the most important part if it can be done.

Four positive integers $w,x,y,z.$ One equation and two inequalities $$ wxyz = (w+x+y+z)^2, $$ $$ w \geq x \geq y \geq z \geq 1, $$ $$ xyz \geq 2(w+x+y+z). $$

I am hoping for an upper bound. Since i made $w$ biggest, it would be an UPPER BOUND on $w.$ For example, I am running a computer program to find all such quadruples with $w \leq 1000.$

Sample question: is it true that $w \leq 1000?$

This is the method of Hurwitz 1907. I have a pdf. His techniques are almost right for this problem, to the point where i am already convinced that the answer to the question by hardmath comes out the exact same way.

EDIT, these imply easily that $$\color{green}{ x+y+z \geq w}. $$ Could be useful.

EDIT: almost forgot, these are what I believe to be all such quadruples:

w  x  y  z     xyz  2(w+x+y+z)
4  4  4  4      64     32
6  6  3  3      52     36
8  5  5  2      50     40
10  10  9  1    90     60
12  6  4  2     48     48   
15  10  3  2    60     60   
18  9  8  1     72     72   
21  14  6  1    84     84   
30  24  5  1   120    120   
1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

Indeed, one can get an upper bound and resolve this equation in general. The cheapest way is to denote $x+y+z=\alpha w$ and note that $\alpha\le 3.$ Plugging this into our equations we end up with:

$$xyz=(\alpha+1)^2w$$ and $$xyz\ge 2(\alpha+1)w.$$ Combining latter, we get $\alpha\ge 1.$ Recall that $x+y+z=\alpha w,$ so $$\frac{xyz}{x+y+z}=\frac{(\alpha+1)^2}{\alpha}\le 3+\frac{1}{3}+2=\frac{16}{3},$$ when $1\le \alpha\le 3.$ So we have the bound $xyz\le \frac{16}{3}(x+y+z)\le \frac{16}{3}(x+x+x)=16x.$ So $yz\le 16.$ One can then proceed and find all solutions.