Intuition Behind Orthogonal Projections

326 Views Asked by At

I am studying functional analysis and orthogonal projections creep up every once in a while in the textbook I am using. After looking over some of the concepts, I am beginning to realize that I may not have as good of an understanding of orthogonal projections (or projections in general for that matter) as I thought from when I studied linear algebra. I have tried looking up some resources, but what I usually find is the projection of a vector onto another, as opposed to the more general notion of projecting along some subspace.

My current understanding is as follows. Suppose $U$ is some subspace of a vector space $V$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$, and suppose that $\{u_n\}$ forms an orthogonal basis for $U$. This implies that for any vector $v \in V$, we may write $$v = a_1u_1 + \ldots + a_nu_n + z,$$ where $a_i \in \mathbb{F}$ and $z \in U^\perp$. Then the orthogonal projection of $v$ along $U$ is a map such that $v \mapsto \hat{v}$, where $$\hat{v} = a_1u_1 + \ldots + a_nu_n.$$

Is this the correct picture or have I misunderstood something?

If this is indeed correct, then I have a few follow-up questions. Namely, how is guaranteed that $V$ can be decomposed into $U$ and $U^\perp$. Also, is a nonorthogonal projection one where the basis vectors of $U$ are not orthogonal (in my example, that would mean $\{u_n\}$ are not necessarily orthogonal). Lastly, how does this picture imply that any projection matrix is idempotent?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

You need an inner product to talk about orthogonality, and you need the space to be complete and $U$ to be closed to be able to write $V=U+U^\perp$. That is, you need a Hilbert space.

The existence of the decomposition is shown to exist by proving that $\{u_n\}$ can be extended to an orthogonal (usually one does orthonormal, but it is not essential). This gives the decomposition $U+U^\perp$, which allows you to define the projection. It is an idempotent because when you write $x=x_U+x_{U^\perp}$ this decomposition is unique. Then $$P^2x=P (Px)=Px_U=x_U=Px,$$ so $P^2=P$.

A non-orthogonal idempotent will be one coming from a decomposition $V=U+U'$, where $U'\cap U=\{0\}$ but $U'$ is not orthogonal to $U$.