Is it possible to construct a Cantor set in a measurable set such that the measure of the constructed Cantor is close to that of the original set?

96 Views Asked by At

According to the Cantor–Bendixson theorem, it is possible to find a perfect set in a compact set of $R^n$ and construct a Cantor set in the perfect set. However, if the compact set has positive Lebesgue measure, can we still construct a Cantor set in it while keeping the measure of the constructed Cantor set close to the measure of the original compact set? My guess is Yes. I try to imitate the standard construction of the Fat Cantor set on the perfect set to make sure that its measure is close to that of the compact set. But I have difficulty proving after the construction, the resultant set is still a Cantor set. Is my guess right? Otherwise, how could I modify my process? Thanks.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On

If we define "Cantor set" to mean a perfect compact set with no interior, then the answer is yes. Suppose for simplicity we're in $\mathbb R,$ $K\subset [0,1]$ is compact, and $m(K)>0.$

Let $\epsilon>0.$ Then there is an open dense subset $U$ of $(0,1)$ such that $m(U)<\epsilon.$ We then have $K\setminus U$ compact and nowhere dense. Furthermore,

$$m(K\setminus U) \ge m(K)-m(U) > m(K)-\epsilon.$$

Now $K\setminus U = P\cup C,$ where $P$ is perfect and $C$ is countable (Cantor-Bendixson). Thus $m(K\setminus U) = m(P).$

So given $\epsilon >0,$ we have found a perfect nowhere dense subset $P$ of $K,$ such that $m(P)\ge m(K)-\epsilon.$