Is the hexagonal cannonball number the only one that ends with $6$?

193 Views Asked by At

I've been searching for cannonball numbers, namely polygonal numbers that are also pyramidal numbers with the same number of sides, patterned after the famous cannonball number $4900$, the square that is also a square pyramidal number. In my initial search I found many numbers that end in $0$, $1$, or $5$, but only one that ends in $6$: $946$, the hexagonal cannonball number which is a hexagon with a side length of $22$ or a hexagonal pyramid $11$ levels high. Is that the only such number?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

The answer is no according to this page which says

(1) $101337426$ is a $145$-agon cannonball number.

(2) $1169686$ is a $322$-agon cannonball number.


The claim $(1)$ is true since $$\frac{(s-2)m^2-(s-4)m}{2}=\frac{(s-2)n^3+3n^2-(s-5)n}{6}=101337426$$ holds for $(s,m,n)=(145,1191,162)$.

The claim $(2)$ is true since $$\frac{(s-2)m^2-(s-4)m}{2}=\frac{(s-2)n^3+3n^2-(s-5)n}{6}=1169686$$ holds for $(s,m,n)=(322,86,28)$.

0
On

I know I'm a little bit late to the chat, but I have done an extensive search through the cannonball numbers and I've found 10 such numbers so far:

(1) The aforementioned 6-agon cannonball number

(2) A 10-agon cannonball number: 368050005576

(3) An 11-agon cannonball number: 7248070597636

(4) A 17-agon cannonball number: 1580765544996

(5,6) The 145 and 322-agons mentioned in the reply by mathlove

(7) A 9325-agon cannonball number: 3176083959788026

(8) A 16420-agon cannonball number: 913053565546276

(9) A 19605-agon cannonball number: 5519583702676

(10) A 125070-agon cannonball number: 890348736143873526

Your post has inspired me to look at my list again, and I've managed to pull out an interesting pattern from the data: While there are clearly quite a few of these numbers that end with 6, all of the cannonball numbers I found (searching as high as a million sides and as high as 2^53) seem to end with either 0, 1, 5, or 6. After doing a bit more research I found that every number of sides congruent to 2 mod(3) that's greater than 5 has at least one solution that can be found with a formula:

$C_s=\frac{1}{162}\left(s^{7}-14s^{6}+66s^{5}-91s^{4}-133s^{3}+309s^{2}+70s-38\right)$

(http://oeis.org/A027696 provides the numbers of sides which don't follow this pattern). All of these seem to only end with the digits 1 or 5. This might be provable with induction, but I have no clue how to prove anything for solutions that don't follow this pattern.

Edit: Just proved that all of the numbers following that polynomial end in 1 or 5 using induction. It's a bit of a pain, and you have to split it into 10 individual cases, but it's definitely doable with a bit of patience and Wolfram Alpha to help expand the polynomials