Is there a generalisation of Catalan's Conjecture hiding in the solution to $(2^m-1) = (2^n-1)k^2$?

122 Views Asked by At

Is there a generalisation of Catalan's Conjecture hiding in the solution to $(2^m-1) = (2^n-1)k^2$?

I ask having noticed the similarity between the answer to this; Solve the equation $(2^m-1) = (2^n-1)k^2$ and the conjecture. Mercury's nontrivial solution is:

$3^2(2^3-1)=2^6-1$

$3^2(2^3-1)=(1+2^3)(2^3-1)$

Dividing throughout by $2^3-1$ we have the sole example of the Catalan statement:

$3^2=2^3-1$

Which suggests to me Mercury's answer may be a generalisation or special case of the (already proven) Catalan's conjecture.

The original question might therefore be generalised as follows:

Let $(2^{pn}-1) = (2^n-1)k^r$

Do $p,n,k,r$ in general obey Catalan's conjecture:

$k^r-p^n=1$

This might be thought of intuitively as; we know $3^2$ is the only perfect square ratio between two Mersenne numbers $M_q$ (where $q$ is not necessarily prime), but is it further the only perfect power?

And generalising further we might conjecture the same identity holds for:

$(p^{pn}-1) = (p^n-1)k^r$