Is this system of three equations solvable in arithmetic operations and root extraction etc

39 Views Asked by At

Is this system of three equations solvable in arithmetic operations and root extraction etc?

$$\begin{array}{cl}x + y + z &= a\\ xyz &= b\\ x^3y^3 +x^3z^3 +z^3y^3 &=c\end{array}$$

If the degree of exponents were same , the solution will just be the factors of a cubic $$(t+x)(t+y)(t+z)=0$$

and substitution method will just result a $9$-th degree equation.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

Yes, $x,y,z$ are solvable using arithmetic operations and root extractions.

Let $u = \frac1x, v = \frac1y, w = \frac1z$ and define

$$\begin{align} A &= u + v + w\\ B &= uv+vw+wu = \frac{x+y+z}{xyz} = \frac{a}{b}\\ C &= uvw = \frac{1}{xyz} = \frac1b\\ p_k &= u^k + v^k + w^k\quad\text{ for } k = 1,2,3\end{align}$$ By Newton's identities, we have

$$\begin{align}p_1 &= A\\ p_2 &= Ap_1 - 2B = A^2 - 2B\\ p_3 &= Ap_2 - Bp_1 + 3C = A^3 - 3BA + 3C \end{align}$$ Notice $$p_3 = u^3 + v^3 + w^3 = \frac1{x^3} + \frac1{y^3} + \frac1{z^3} = \frac{c}{b^3}$$

$A$ is a root of the cubic equation $$t^3 - \frac{3a}{b}t + \left(\frac3b - \frac{c}{b^3}\right) = 0$$ Using Cardano's formula for depressed cubic, we can compute $A$ using arithmetic operations and root extractions from $\frac{3a}{b}$ and $\frac3b - \frac{c}{b^3}$.

Once we get $A$, $u,v,w$ are roots of the cubic equations $$t^3 - At^2 + Bt + C = 0$$ Transform the cubic equation to a depressed one and apply Cardano's formula again, we can compute $u,v,w$ (and hence $x,y,z$) using arithmetic operations and roots extractions from $A,B,C$ (and hence from $a,b,c$).

The actual formula for $u,v,w$ will be a nightmare, I will leave the fun to you.