Locus of points whose distance between two 3D lines is at a given ratio

246 Views Asked by At

I'm aware that a very similar question has been asked before (Question 888147) but this one is its 3D version, which doesn't seem to easily generalize.

I'm given two lines $\ell_1$ and $\ell_2$ that intersect at the origin, and I'd like to know what the locus of the points such that $$\text{d}(X,\ell_1)=k\cdot\text{d}(X,\ell_2)$$ looks like.

I know that if a point $X$ has this property, multiplying it by a scalar yields another point with it, which leads me to suspect the shape I'm looking for is some kind of double cone (or two of them, as analogy with the 2D case makes me suspect), but I'm clueless on how to prove this.

Since I don't even have a formula for distances between points and lines in 3D in terms of the coordinates, I really don't know where to start.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

A formula for the distance from a point to a line shows that the condition $\operatorname d((x, y, z), l_2) = k \operatorname d((x, y, z), l_1)$ gives a quadric surface. The quadric is symmetric wrt the plane containing $l_1$ and $l_2$. If we already know that the cross-section by this plane is a pair of lines and also know that the quadric is not a pair of planes for $k \neq 1$, it follows that the only possibility is a cone.

If we choose a coordinate system such that $l_1$ goes through the origin in the $x$ direction and $l_2$ goes through the origin in the direction $(\cos \phi, \sin \phi, 0)$ and rotate the lines by the angle $$-\arctan(k^2 - \cos 2 \phi, -\sin 2\phi)/2$$ around the $z$ axis from the positive $x$ direction to the positive $y$ direction to eliminate the $x y$ term, the equation of the cone becomes $$\frac {1 - k^2 + \rho} 2 x^2 + \frac {1 - k^2 - \rho} 2 y^2 + (1 - k^2) z^2 = 0, \\ \rho = \sqrt {1 + k^4 - 2 k ^2 \cos 2 \phi}.$$

0
On

For any couple of distinct lines, it is always possible to find some coordinates transformation such that the 2 lines, in the new coordinate system, lies over 2 of the 3 axis, let's say over x and y axis. Now, the locus of points at a distance $d$ from a line is a cyclinder, so we have the intersection of 2 cylinders. The intersection looks like a kind of "bent" circle.
Varying the diameter of one cylinder and keeping the ratio with the other cylinder constant, we got the projection from the origin of this bent circle. So, yes, in the end we have something like a double cone. Going back to original coordinate system, we retain a cone like shape.