m∗(E)=sup{m∗(K):K⊂E, with K compact} holds even m*(E) = infty?

56 Views Asked by At

The problem is : Let $E\subset R$ be an arbitrary measurable set. Then, $m^∗(E) = \sup$ { $m^∗(K): K ⊂ E, K :$ closed and bounded(which means it's compact) }

($m^∗$ is Lebesgue outer measure.)

I know how to solve this problem when $m^*(E) < \infty$ (Also, there was such a nice answer when $m^*(E) < \infty$) But, it was hard for me to solve this when the measure of E becomes infinite.(And, there was no idea I could find "$m^*(E) = \infty$")

I tried to get $m^*(E) = N $ and make N sufficiently big, so that it goes to infinity. But, since all $K$ is bounded, I don't know if this idea is right.

Could you give me a nicer solution or good tip to solve in infinity?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

Suppose $m^{*}(E)=\infty$. Then, given any $M>0$ there exists $N$ such that $m^{*}(E \cap [-N,N]) >M$. There is a closed and bounded set $K \subseteq E \cap [-N,N]$ such that $m^{*} (K) >m^{*} (E \cap [-N,N])-\epsilon$. Can you finish?