Misconception about proof by cases

53 Views Asked by At

Let $x,y \in \mathbb{R}$, s.t. $y>0$. Then $|x|<y \iff -y < x < y$.

I'm confused about how to join the cases in this proof into a single interval.

By definition, $|x|= x$ if $x \geq0$ and $|x|=-x$ if $x<0$. So the proof lends itself to two cases.

Case 1: $x \geq 0$

Then $|x|<y \implies x<y$

Case 2: $x < 0$

Then $|x|<y \implies -x<y \implies x>-y$

But the cases are joined by an "or" statement, as opposed to an "and" statement, correct?

So it would be wrong to conclude that the solution lies in the intersection. That is, I cannot immediately conclude $-y<x<y$.

So, what am I missing?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

$$|x|<y\implies x\le \max (x,-x)=|x|<y\implies x<y.$$ $$|x|<y\implies -x\le \max (x,-x)=|x|<y\implies -x<y\implies x>-y.$$