Modification of the Ramsey number

251 Views Asked by At

Let us denote by $n=r(k_1,k_2,\ldots,k_s)$ the minimal number of vertices such that for every coloring of the edges of the complete graph $K_n$ by $s$ different colors, there is some color $1\le i\le s$ such that the $i$-th graph contains a $k_i$ clique. By the $i$-th graph we mean the graph on the given $n$ vertices and this edges of the complete graph that are colored $i$.

let us denote $r_s = r(3,3,3,3,\ldots)$, with $3$ appearing $s$ times.

a) show that $r(k,s)$ is exactly the regular Ramsey number.
b) show that $r_s \le s(r_{s-1}-1)+ 2$.
c) show that $r_s \le s! \cdot e + 1$.
d) show that $r_3 \le 17$.

Now I don't get how to even start solving this, considering (c) for example, I don't see how we can achieve a factorial... Any hints for the solution, or a better explanation of the definition will be really helpful, thank you!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

The definition seems clear enough, especially if you've seen Ramsey numbers before. The questions are all about the special case of $r_s$, which is just the smallest $n$ such that every coloring of the edges of $K_n$ with $s$ colors contains a monochromatic triangle, that is, a triangle whose edges are all the same color; e.g., $r_1=3$, $r_2=6$.

a) I hope this follows directly from the definitions.

b) Have you seen a proof of an upper bound for the "regular" Ramsey numbers? This is a lot like that. Pick a point $v$, consider the edges incident with $v$, and use the pigeonhole principle to show that enough of them are of the same color. [*]

c) This is misstated. The upper bound should be $\lfloor s!e\rfloor+1$ where $e=2.718\dots$ is the base of natural logarithms and $\lfloor x\rfloor$ is the floor function; e.g., if $s=2$ then $\lfloor s!e\rfloor+1=6$. Prove by induction on $s$, using b) and the fact that, for $s\ge1$, $$\lfloor s!e\rfloor=\frac{s!}{0!}+\frac{s!}{1!}+\frac{s!}{2!}+\cdots+\frac{s!}{s!}.$$

d) Just set $s=3$ in c) and do the calculation.

[*] Consider an integer $s\gt1$, let $n=s(r_{s-1}-1)+2$, and suppose the edges of $K_n$ are colored with $s$ colors. Choose a vertex $v$ and consider the $n-1=s(r_{s-1}-1)+1$ edges incident with $v$. By the pigeonhole principle, at least $r_{s-1}$ of those edges have the same color, which I will call "red". That is, there is a set $W\subset V(K_n)$ of size $|W|=r_{s-1}$ such that each vertex in $W$ is joined to $v$ by a red edge. If two vertices $w_1,w_2\in W$ are joined to each other by a red edge, then $v,w_1,w_2$ are the vertices of a red triangle. On the other hand, if no two vertices in $W$ are joined by a red edge, then the edges of the complete graph on $W$ are colored with $s-1$ colors, and the existence of a monochromatic triangle follows from the definition of $r_{s-1}$. This proves that $r_s\le n=s(r_{s-1}-1)+2$.