Moment of inertia - formula derivation: Missing $\frac{1}{2}$

1.1k Views Asked by At

I'm trying to deduce the formula of the moment of inertia of an object of rotation. The general formula for the moment of inertia is declared as:

$$J=m*r^2 =\sum{m_i * r_i^2}$$

If I replace $m_i$ of the $\sum{m_i * r_i^2}$ with $\int dm$ (where dm are the masses) and $r_i^2$ with the $\int(y)^2dx$, I get $J=\int y^2 dm = \int y^2*(\rho\space dV)$ (remember: $(\rho\space dV)$ since $\rho=\frac{m}{V}$)

Furthermore $V=\int{\pi*y^2}dx$ leads me to $J = \int y^2*(\rho\space dV) = \int y^2 * \rho*\pi*y^2 dx = $

$$J=\pi*\rho*\int y^4 dx$$

Now my question: If I compare my formula with the formula it should be, I perceive that there is $\frac{1}{2}$ missing.

$$J=\frac{\pi*\sigma}{{\color{red}2}}*\int y^4 dx$$

What mistake did I make?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

The problem is that you didn't trace the meaning of $y$ through the formulas. The $y$ in

$$J=\int y^2\,\mathrm dm$$

is the $y$ coordinate of a mass element in the body, whereas the $y$ in

$$V=\int\pi y^2\,\mathrm dx$$

and in

$$J=\frac{\pi\rho}2\int y^4\,\mathrm dx$$

is the $y$ coordinate of the curve forming the boundary of the body. In replacing $\mathrm dm$ by $\rho\,\mathrm d V$ with $\mathrm dV$ representing an entire infinitesimal disk of the body of rotation, you'd have to average $y^2$ over the disk. However, I get a factor of $1/4$ from that, not $1/2$, so there might be another problem, too.