Odd number of reals with equal partitions

425 Views Asked by At

Consider the following problem:

You are given a multiset (a set with repetitions allowed) of $2n+1$ real numbers, say $S = \{r_1, \dots, r_{2n+1}\}$.

These numbers are such that for every $k$, the multiset $S - \{r_k\}$ can be split into two multisets of size $n$ each, such that the sum of numbers in one multiset is same as the sum of numbers in the other.

Show that all the numbers must be equal.( i.e. $r_{i} = r_{j}$)

Please stop reading further if you want to try and solve this problem.

Spoiler:

Now this problem can easily be solved using Linear Algebra. We have a set of $2n+1$ linear equations, which corresponds to a matrix equation $Ar = 0$. It can be shown that $A$ has rank at least $2n$ which implies the result.

The question is, is there any solution to this problem which does not involve any linear algebra?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

You can't avoid some sort of algebra, because the statement is false in a commutative group where $nx = 0$ has nontrivial solutions.

If you allow use of the linear algebra fact that rank is the same over any field containing the coefficients of the equations, it is enough to consider rational (and thus integer) solutions and extra structure is available. One can then avoid use of determinants or matrices:

If $\Sigma$ is the sum of all elements, $\Sigma - r_i$ is even and thus all $r_i$ have the same parity. We can replace each $r_i$ by $(r_i-r_k)/2$ and get a smaller solution, where $r_k$ is the smallest of the numbers. This process ends at the zero solution, and is reversible, so the original solution has all numbers equal.

(added: you can consider this a use of either the real or 2-adic metric on integers, so this must correspond to a linear algebra argument using inequalities or reduction mod 2^(2n+1) on the system of equations or its determinant.)