Picking one of each color

46 Views Asked by At

There are $a$ balls of color A, $b$ balls of color B, $c$ balls of color C in the bag and $d$ balls of color D in a bag. What are the chances that when I take four balls out of the bag at the same time, I take out one of each color?

So I realised that there were $^{a+b+c+d}C_{4}$ ways of picking them. I also realised that there were $4!$ permutations of picking. How go from here?

4

There are 4 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Combinations is the most natural approach.

  • Choose $1$ ball from $A$:$\;{\large{\binom{a}{1}}}$ choices.
  • Choose $1$ ball from $B$:$\;{\large{\binom{b}{1}}}$ choices.
  • Choose $1$ ball from $C$:$\;{\large{\binom{c}{1}}}$ choices.
  • Choose $1$ ball from $D$:$\;{\large{\binom{d}{1}}}$ choices.

By the multiplication rule, there are $$ {\small{\binom{a}{1}}} {\small{\binom{b}{1}}} {\small{\binom{c}{1}}} {\small{\binom{d}{1}}} =abcd $$ sets of $4$ balls, with one from each of $A,B,C,D$.

Since the number of possible sets of $4$ balls is $${\small{\binom{a+b+c+d}{4}}}$$ it follows that the required probability is $$ \frac { abcd } { {\large{\binom{a+b+c+d}{4}}} } $$ Notice that this approach would work just as well if you were asked, for example, to find the probability of selecting $10$ balls with

  • $1$ ball from $A$
  • $2$ balls from $B$
  • $3$ balls from $C$
  • $4$ balls from $D$

assuming $a+b+c+d\ge 10$.

Following the same approach, the required probability would be $$ \frac { \binom{a}{1}\binom{b}{2}\binom{c}{3}\binom{d}{4} } { {\large{\binom{a+b+c+d}{10}}} } $$

0
On

So you are going to put $^{a+b+c+d}C_{4}=\binom{a+b+c+d}{4}$ at the denominator. Then, as regards the numerator of the fraction which gives the probability, consider the product $abcd$: we have $a$ ways to pick a ball of color A, $b$ ways to pick a ball ball of color B...

3
On

Ive got it!! There are 24 permutations possible. Each permutation has the probability of $\frac{abcd}{^{a+b+c+d}C_4}$ Multiply this by 24, and dada!

Please check this; I am not so sure.

0
On

Suppose we extract

  • ball A $p=\frac{a}(n)$
  • ball B $p=\frac{b}(n-1)$
  • ball C $p=\frac{c}(n-2)$
  • ball D $p=\frac{d}(n-3)$

and we have 4! different ways.