Plane curve in tropical geometry with "multiplicative inverse"

81 Views Asked by At

I am new to tropical geometry with addition is the $\max$ and multiplication the usually $+$ and I am trying to understand the translation of polynomials from the tropical setting to the classical setting. For example the abstract structure $$a\odot x^2\oplus b\odot x\oplus c= \max\lbrace 2x+a,x+b,c\rbrace$$ is clear but I am struggeling with the inverse way, if there is the multiplicative inverse involved for the reals. For example what is in tropical notation

$$p(x,y)=2\max\lbrace x,y\rbrace-(x+y)=\max\lbrace x,y\rbrace+\max\lbrace -x,-y\rbrace=?$$

I do not manage to resolve the negative signs here. Intuitively, it should be the analog of

$$q(x,y)=\frac{2(x+y)}{xy}$$ but this is not a polynomial.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

Since the tropical multiplication is nothing else than the usual addition, it forms an abelian group. In consequence, each element possesses an inverse element with respect to multiplication, namely $x^{\odot-1} = -x$. N.B. : more generally, a tropical power can be defined as $x^{\odot n} = x \odot \ldots \odot x = n \cdot x$. You might introduce a new symbol, such as a circled division, in order to represent the tropical division.

Let's work on the first part of $p(x,y)$; one has : $$ p_1(x,y) := 2\max(x,y) = (x \oplus y)^{\odot2} = (x \oplus y) \odot (x \oplus y) = x^{\odot2} \oplus (x \odot y) \oplus (y \odot x) \oplus y^{\odot2} $$ where we used the distributivity of tropical multiplication over tropical addition. Now, the middle expression with the mixed products can be simplified thanks to the commutativity of tropical multiplication, i.e. $x \odot y = y \odot x$, as well as the idempotency of tropical addition, i.e. $a \oplus a = \max(a,a) = a$, so that $$ 2\max(x,y) = x^{\odot2} \oplus (x \odot y) \oplus y^{\odot2} $$

The second part of $p(x,y)$ is simply translated as $p_2(x,y) := -(x+y) = (x \odot y)^{\odot-1} = x^{\odot-1} \odot y^{\odot-1}$. It is then gathered together with the first part of $p(x,y)$ as follows : $$ p = p_1 + p_2 = p_1 \odot p_2 = \left(x^{\odot2} \oplus (x \odot y) \oplus y^{\odot2}\right) \odot x^{\odot-1} \odot y^{\odot-1} = (x \odot y^{\odot-1}) \oplus 0 \oplus (x^{\odot-1} \odot y), $$ where we used the distibutivity of $\odot$ over $\oplus$ again and the fact that $0$ is the identity element of $\odot$. The last expression can be considered as a standard bivariate tropical (Laurent) polynomial, which is indeed the tropical analog of $\frac{(x+y)^2}{xy} = xy^{-1} + 1 + x^{-1}y$.