problem understanding Systems of distinct representatives

227 Views Asked by At

I have been given the problem

"Let P={S_1,S_2,...,S_r} be a family of distinct nonempty subsets of the set {1,2,...,n}. If the S_i are all of the same cardinality (|S_i|=k), then prove that there exists an System of Distinct Representatives (SDR) of P."

I don't understand how this can be true. Take, for example, n=10 and k=6. There are (n!)/(k!(n-k)!) distinct subsets of cardinality k, so for the example, there are 10!/(6!*4!) = 210 possible distinct subsets of size 6. Suppose that P contained all of these subsets. Then the SDR would require 210 distinct values, but we only have 10. Obviously I'm missing something, but I just don't see how this is possible. Thanks.

Update: I have checked over the textbook and i have quoted the problem correctly. This isn't the first time that I have found a typo in the textbook so it is more than likely that the question is simply wrong. I have reached out to my instructor and I will post an update when I have an answer. Thank you.

Update: The question is taken from Combinatorics and Graph Theory 2nd edition (J.M Harris, J.L Hirst, M.J Mossinghoff). The question is exercise 4 from section 1.7.2. I have spoken with my instructor and apparently we are supposed to prove this is true for certain values of r, not all values.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

The condition for the existence of SDR would basically be that $r\le n$. Because, just suppose that $r>n$. Now we have $n$ elements that can represent and more than $n$ members to be represented. So basically by pigeon hole principle atleast one element was used more than once for representing the members.