Proof check regarding a simple real analysis problem about the intersections of sets

56 Views Asked by At

Good day to everyone, can you please provide feedback on my personal attempt to prove this simple statement (a problem from Rudin's Principles of Math Analysis)?

Let A be the set of real numbers x such that $0 < \mathit{x} \leq 1$. For every $\mathit{x} \in \mathbf{A}$ let $\mathbf{E}_x$ be the set of real numbers y such that $0 < \mathit{y} < \mathit{x}$. Then the intersection $\bigcap_{x \in A} \mathbf{E}_{x}$ is empty.

My proof (by contradiction): Assume the intersection is not empty. That means at least one y exists which belongs to every $\mathbf{E}_{x}$. Since it belongs to every $\mathbf{E}_{x}$, obviously y has to be the smallest possible real number within A (if there was some x for which $y > x$, then y would not be a common element for every possible $\mathbf{E}_{x}$). 0 is the infimum of A. If y is the smallest element and $0 < y$, 0 is clearly not the infimum, which contradicts our definition and finishes the proof.

Please point out any flaws in my reasoning, I am trying to get back to understanding solid mathematics.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

You've got the right idea. Maybe say that $y\le x,\,\forall x\in A$, instead of "$y$ is obviously the least element in A", since $A$ has no least element.

Direct proof:

Let $y\in A$. Then $\frac y2\in A$ and $0\lt \frac y2\lt y$. Thus $y\not\in E_{\frac y2}$. Thus $y\not\in\bigcap_{x\in A} E_x$. Thus $\bigcap_{x\in A} E_x=\emptyset$.