Prove $|n^s| = n^{Re(s)}$

106 Views Asked by At

How can one prove that $|n^s|= n^{Re(s)}$, where $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $s \in \mathbb{C}$, such that $Re(s) > 1$ (I found this on the link Convergence of $\zeta(s)$ on $\Re(s)> 1$)? I tried: $|n ^s|= |e^{ s log n}| = | e^{ s( ln(n) + i Arg (n) + 2 k \pi i) } |= |e^{ s( ln(n) + 2 k \pi i) }| = | e^{ (x + iy ) (ln (n) + 2 k \pi i) } | = | e^{x ln (n) + i y ln(n) +2 k \pi x i - 2 k \pi y )} | = | e^{x ln (n) - 2 k \pi y } | = n^x e^{- 2 k \pi y } $.

How do we obtain $n^x$?

3

There are 3 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

Assuming that $s = x + iy$, and following this link, then:

$$n^s = n^{x+iy} = n^x \cdot n^{iy} = n^x \cdot e^{iy\log(n)}.$$

Recall that:

$$e^{iy\log(n)} = \cos(y \log(n)) + i \sin(y \log(n)),$$

and hence:

$$|e^{iy\log(n)}| = \sqrt{\cos^2(y \log(n)) + \sin^2(y \log(n))} = 1.$$

As a consequence:

$$|n^s| = |n^x| \cdot |e^{iy \log(n)}| = n^x \cdot 1 = n^x.$$

But $x = \text{Re}(s)$, and hence:

$$|n^s| = n^{\text{Re}(s)}.$$

0
On

On one hand we could have this reasoning:

$n^s=n^{a+ib}=n^a\times n^{ib}$

And since $n^{ib}=\exp(ib\ln n)=e^{i\theta}\quad$ with $\theta=b\ln n$ so it is of module $1$.

Yet actually the premises $n^{a+ib}=n^a\cdot n^{ib}$ is false in general if you consider complex exponentiation.

But we generally assume the definition $b^z=\exp(z\ln b)$ when $b$ is a positive real, where $\exp$ is defined by its power series.

See this Definition of exponential function, single-valued or multi-valued?

Therefore it is really a matter of conventions, the result $|n^z|=n^a$ is fine according to this latter convention, but yours is the correct one assuming the complex exponentiation convention.

0
On

Try using the definition $|z| = \sqrt{\overline{z}z}$, for $s = x+iy$ \begin{align*} |n^s| & = \sqrt{\overline{n^s}\cdot n^s} \\ & = \sqrt{\overline{n^{x+iy}}\cdot n^{x+iy}} \\ & = \sqrt{n^{x-iy}\cdot n^{x+iy}} \\ & = \sqrt{n^{x}n^{-iy} n^{x}n^{iy}} \\ & = \sqrt{n^{2x}n^{iy-iy}} \\ & = \sqrt{n^{2x}n^{0}} \\ & = \sqrt{n^{2x}} \\ & = n^{x} \\ \end{align*}