Prove that $I-A$ is non singular

71 Views Asked by At

If $A$ is a skew-symmetric Matrix then prove that $I-A$ is non singular, where $I$ is the identity Matrix of the order equal to that of $A$.

I know that this question can be done by using the concept of eigenvalues. But I want a solution that does not involve that. I have one solution but it is like very difficult to think.

My approach

We see that the matrix $(I-A)(I+A)^{-1}$ is orthogonal. Hence we can say that $\frac{\det(I-A)}{\det(I+A)}=1$ so $\det(I-A)\ne0$

This solution is nice but hard to think.

Second approach (Solution given in book)

Consider a homogeneous system of equation $(I-A)X=0$ $\implies AX=X$

Now, $$(AX)^{T}=X^T$$ $$\implies -X^TA=X^T$$ Now post multiplying by $X$ gives, $$X^TX=0$$ now the book says $\implies X=0$ so $(I-A)X$ has only trivial solution. And hence $\det(I-A)\ne0$

I cannot understand how they concluded that $X$ is $0$. How did they just cancel $X^T?$


I want you guys to give nice solutions of this problem and if possible pls explain the last step in the second solution.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

The statement in question is false if the elements of $A$ are taken from a general field. E.g. the complex matrix $$ I_2-\pmatrix{0&i\\ -i&0}=\pmatrix{1&-i\\ i&1}=\pmatrix{1\\ i}\pmatrix{1&-i} $$ is singular.

The author of your book has probably implicitly assumed that the underlying field is real. First, observe that when $A$ is a skew-symmetric matrix over a field of characteristic $\ne2$, we must have $X^TAX=0$ for every vector $X$, because \begin{align*} X^TAX &=(X^TAX)^T\quad\text{(as $X^TAX$ is a $1\times1$ matrix)}\\ &=X^TA^TX^T\\ &=-X^TAX^T.\\ \end{align*} (We actually also have $X^TAX=0$ in a field of characteristic $2$, if the definition of skew-symmetric matrix requires that the matrix to have a zero diagonal.)

In particular, $X^TAX=0$ when the field is $\mathbb R$. Now, if $(I-A)X=0$, then $X=AX$. In turn, $\sum_ix_i^2=X^TX=X^TAX=0$. Since all $x_i$s are real numbers, each of them must be zero. Hence $X$ is necessarily zero and $I-A$ is nonsingular.