Prove that if $|A|<|B|$ and both A and B are linearly indepdent, then not: $B\subseteq sp(A)$

30 Views Asked by At

I need to prove that if $|A|<|B|$ and both $A$ and $B$ are linearly indepdent, then it is not the case that: $B\subseteq A$ (ie. there is $a\in B$, such that $a\notin sp(A)$. No advanced theorems...

So $A$ and $B$ are both linearly independent that is

$\sum_{a\in A} \lambda_a a=0$

$\sum_{b\in B} \lambda_b b=0$

Only if all the lambdas are zero. Since $|A|<|B|$, there are more elements in $B$ than in $A$. What is the best way to continue the proof from here? Inductively it is straight forward to prove if for finite case:

Suppose $|B|=1$:

There is nothing in $sp(A)$ so the case follows trivially.

Now assume that the case holds for $|B|=n$.

Now add an element $b^*$ to $B$, since it's linearly independent, this new element is

$\sum_{b\in B} \lambda_b b\neq b^*$

Also add an element $a^*$ to $A$, so:

$\sum_{a\in A} \lambda_a a\neq a^*$

Now if $a^*=b^*$ there is an element in $B$ that is not in $A$. And if $a^*$ is that element, then $b^*$ is in $B$, but not in $A$.

Is this completely backwards? Would it be more appropriate to use induction on $|A\triangle B|$? What about the infinite case?