Prove that there exist at most two parabolas passing through four given points.

101 Views Asked by At

Prove that there exist at most two parabolas passing through four given points.

I recently get this:

If I have five points $(x_i,y_i),i=1,2,\ldots, 5$, I can represent the conic section by this determinant. $$ \begin{vmatrix} {1}&x&y&{xy}&{x^2}&{y^2} \\ {1}&{x_1}&{y_1}&{x_1y_1}&{x_1^2}&{y_1^2} \\ {1}&{x_2}&{y_2}&{x_2y_2}&{x_2^2}&{y_2^2} \\ {1}&{x_3}&{y_3}&{x_3y_3}&{x_3^2}&{y_3^2} \\ {1}&{x_4}&{y_4}&{x_4y_4}&{x_4^2}&{y_4^2} \\ {1}&{x_5}&{y_5}&{x_5y_5}&{x_5^2}&{y_5^2} \end{vmatrix}=0 $$

So I think: if I have four points, in theory, I will get at most 2 parabolas. But what I only know is: for $$Ax^2+2Bxy+Cy^2+\cdots=0$$ $\Delta=B^2-AC=0$ means a parabola.

Can I prove what I thought with this determinant?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Here,I have a not so rigorous prove. Consider this two curves that pass through four given points.

$$ T_1:A_1x^2+B_1 xy+C_1y^2+D_1x+E_1y+F_1=0\\ T_2:A_2x^2+B_2 xy+C_2y^2+D_2x+E_2y+F_2=0 $$

then we write it like this.

$$ (λ_1A_1+λ_2A_2)x^2+(λ_1B_1+λ_2B_2)xy+(λ_1C_1+λ_2C_2)y^2+⋯=0 $$

(since $Dx,Ey,F$ is unimportant to think about.)

apply $B^2-4AC=0$

$$(λ_1B_1+λ_2B_2)^2-4(λ_1A_1+λ_2A_2)(λ_1C_1+λ_2C_2)=0$$

expand it ,and we will get

$$\tag{1}(XX)λ_1^2+(YY)λ_1λ_2+(ZZ)λ_2^2=0$$

it's a Homogeneous equation.

At most it has two solutions. That is to say,we get 2 pairs of $\lambda_1,\lambda_2$,so we get two parabolas.