Proving an equation is false, through contradiction

72 Views Asked by At

I need to either prove or disprove this statement.

$(\exists y\in R)(\forall x \in R)(2x-y=3)$

I want to provide a proof by contradiction, so I'm proving the negation

$(\forall y\in R)(\exists x \in R)(2x-y \neq 3)$

Proof:

Suppose y = 1 and x =3 then $2(3)-3 =5 \neq 3$

therefore $(\exists y\in R)(\forall x \in R)(2x-y=3)$ is false.

From what I'm reading this is sufficient proof, but I can't convince myself this is totally correct, but know of no other way to go about it. Any help would be great. Thanks!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

If you want to prove the negation $(\forall y\in R)(\exists x \in R)(2x-y \neq 3)$, you have to stick to the statement. The negation claims that for each real number $y$ there is $x$ such that $2x-y \neq 3$. So, to prove this, for every $y$ you have to find an $x$, not only for one special $y$.