I've known for some time about the rotation group action of the ('pure') quaternions on $ \mathbf{R}^3 $ by conjugation. I've recently encountered spinors and notice similarities in their definitions (for example, the use of half-angles for rotations).
Is the relationship that this suggested in my mind a real one, and if so what is its formal nature? Are the spaces isomorphic? If not, is there any relationship at all?
Yes, quaternions are related to spinous in three dimensions. You might first try the subsection of the spinor wiki talking about quaternions where it mentions
See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinors_in_three_dimensions . The very first paragraph after the lead paragraph starts into quaternions.
More generally, spinors of higher dimension are related to Clifford algebras. The quaternions can be considered a special case of a Clifford algebra.