Question about Q-analogs

68 Views Asked by At

I am trying to prove the following

Given $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we define $[n]_{q} = (1-q^{n})/(1-q)$.

We also define $[n]_{q} ! = [n-1]_{q} ! \cdot [n]_{q}$, with $[1]_{q} ! =1$.

Then I want to prove the following

Given compositions $\lambda$, $\mu$ we say $\mu \geq \lambda$ if $$ \lambda_{1} = \mu_{1} + \ldots + \mu_{i_{1}} $$ $$ \lambda_{2} = \mu_{i_{1}+1} + \mu_{i_{1}+2} + \ldots + \mu_{i_{2}} $$ Etc, in other words if one sees $\lambda$ as a division of the interval $[1, \ldots , | \lambda | ]$ then $ \mu \geq \lambda$ if $\mu$ has the same divisions than $\lambda$ and possibly more. For example $\lambda = (3,2,1)$ can be seen as $123|45|6$ and $\mu=2121$ can be seen as $12|3|45|6$. In this case $\mu \geq \lambda$.

Given a composition $\lambda$, we define $$ f_{\lambda} (q) = \prod_{i=1}^{ \ell (\lambda) } [ \lambda_{i} ]_{q} !^{-1} $$ I want to prove that $$ f_{\lambda} \left( \dfrac{1}{q} \right) = \sum_{\mu \geq \lambda} f_{\mu} (q) (-1)^{\ell (\mu )- | \lambda |} $$ As the function is defined multiplicatively, I know that this follows if I can prove it for $\lambda = (\lambda_{1})$.

Do anyone knows any reference in which I could look for theory that could aid me to come up with a proof?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

After trying again induction, but this time using all the previous terms, I think I have succeded.

We want to prove \begin{equation} \label{Eq1} f_{m} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) = \sum_{ | \lambda | = m} f_{\lambda} (q) (-1)^{\ell ( \lambda ) + | \lambda | } \qquad (1) \end{equation} First, we divide the compositions of $m$ on the following sets: the ones that end with a block of size $1$, they are $2^{m-1}$, the ones that end with a block of size $2$, they are $2^{m-2}$, and so. There is only $1$ that ends with a block of size $m-1$ and only one that ends with a block of size $m$. So $$ \sum_{ | \lambda | = m} f_{\lambda} (q) (-1)^{\ell ( \lambda ) + | \lambda | } = \sum_{0 \leq n < m} \sum_{ | \mu | = n} f_{\mu} (q) (-1)^{\ell ( \mu ) +1 + | \mu | +(m-n) } \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} $$

If we assume by strong induction that $(1)$ holds for $n<m$, then this is is equal to $$ \sum_{0 \leq n < m} (-1)^{m-n+1} f_{n} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} = (-1)^{1+m} \sum_{0 \leq n < m} (-1)^{n} f_{n} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} $$ We add $f_{m}(1/q)$ to this, and we obtain $$ (-1)^{1+m} \sum_{0 \leq n < m} (-1)^{n} f_{n} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} +(-1)^{2m+1} f_{m} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) = $$

$$ = (-1)^{1+m} \sum_{0 \leq n \leq m} (-1)^{n} f_{n} \left( \frac{1}{q} \right) \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} $$

A straightfoward computation shows that $f_{n} (1/q) = q^{n(n-1)/2}$.

$$ (-1)^{1+m} \sum_{0 \leq n \leq m} (-1)^{n} q^{n(n-1)/2} f_{n} \left( q \right) \dfrac{1}{ [m - n ]_{q} !} $$ By definition $f_{n}(q) = [n]_{q}!^{-1}$, we replace on the expresion and obtain.

$$ (-1)^{1+m} \sum_{0 \leq n \leq m} (-1)^{n} q^{(n-1)n/2} \dfrac{1}{ [n]_{q}! [m - n ]_{q} !} $$ If we multiply this by $f_{m}(1/q)^{-1}=[m]_{q}! (-1)^{1+m}$, then we get $$ \sum_{0 \leq n \leq m} (-1)^{n} q^{(n-1)n/2} \dfrac{ [m]_{q}! }{ [n]_{q}! [m - n ]_{q} !} $$ Which by Gauss Binomial Formula (found on page 15, equation (5.5) of Quantum Calculus Victor Kac) with $a=-1$ and $x=1$ this is $0$.

So $ f_{m}(1/q) = \sum_{| \mu | = m} f_{\mu} (q) (-1)^{\ell ( \mu ) + | \lambda |}$.