Question on convex pentagons with lattice points as its vertices

98 Views Asked by At

I have the following question which I found as an example in a book with me:

"All vertices of a convex pentagon are lattice points, and its sides have integral length. Show that its perimeter is even"

The book starts the solution like this:

"Colour the lattices as in a chess board and erect right triangles on the sides of the pentagon with the sides of the pentagon as the longest side. With the other two sides along the sides of the square trace the ten shorter sides. Since at the end we return to the point we started we must have traced an even number of lattice points."

How is the last statement concluded?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

There are two parts to that reasoning:

  • Replacing a slanted edge with two edges in the axial directions doesn't change whether the perimeter is odd. This follows from the fact that every primitive Pythagorean triple has exactly one odd leg and an odd hypotenuse; we either replace odd with odd+even or even with even+even.
  • A closed lattice polygon with all sides in the axial directions must have even perimeter. This is what the chessboard coloring (best done with the squares centered at lattice points) is for; we alternate colors with every 1 unit we travel, and eventually return to the start. That's an even number of changes, for an even total distance.
    Alternately, we can show that the sum of the edges in the $x$-direction and the sum of the edges in the $y$-direction are both even, by similar reasoning in one dimension.